It doesn’t speak well of Islam that when Muslim’s think more seriously about their religion, some of them get more violent. One test of this thesis is to see what happens after Muslims make pilgrimages and attend religious schools. Do they become more peaceful or more violent, more compassionate or more angry?
Another way to slice the data is to look at what happens to Muslims during the special days of the year when they focus more on religion. Liberal Boston Globe writer James Carroll notes what happens during the holy month of Ramadan
In the four years of the Iraqi war, a so-called “Ramadan spike” has marked the period as among the most deadly. Last week’s assassination of Sunni leader Abdul-Sattar Abu Risha, who had recently welcomed President Bush to Anbar Province, was doubly shocking for coming at the start of Ramadan. What began as a manifestation of devotion becomes, in periods of conflict, a prompt to zealotry that can include savage violence.
During the Algerian civil war in the 1990s Ramadan was the most dangerous period for the enemies of the radical Islamist rebels, with “lax” Muslims, like intellectuals, being especially targeted. In Egypt and Syria, what is known in Israel and the United States as the Yom Kippur War is called the Ramadan War, since it was launched at the start of the holy month. Again this year, Ramadan overlaps with Yom Kippur, which comes this week.
So here is a second point of data that some Muslims become more violent as they think more about their religion. If there are other Muslims who become more compassionate and more willing to take risks for peace when they think about their religion, these people have not gotten any publicity.
So not to pick on Muslims, it should be noted that Easter used to be a time noted for anti-Semitism, when Jews were attacked for their alleged responsibility for killing Christ. On the other hand, there is an emphasis on peace at Christmas, and there even was a Christmas truce during World War I in 1914, though it was not repeated in subsequent years.